Rating Pemain Man Utd Vs Newcastle: Zirkzee Habis?

Wanagama

You need 5 min read

·

Post on Dec 31, 2024

50 visitor like this post

Share

Rating Pemain Man Utd vs Newcastle: Zirkzee Habis?

The Manchester United versus Newcastle match was a captivating encounter, leaving fans debating the performances of individual players. While the overall result might be the headline, a deeper dive into the individual ratings reveals a fascinating narrative, especially concerning the much-anticipated performance (or lack thereof) of young striker, Zirkzee. Let's break down the performances, player by player, and answer the burning question: was Zirkzee's impact truly negligible?

Manchester United Player Ratings: A Mixed Bag of Performances

Goalkeeper:

• Andre Onana (7.5/10): Onana commanded his area with confidence, making several key saves, especially in the second half when Newcastle pushed for an equalizer. His distribution was also sharp, initiating several promising attacks. While not flawless, his performance was a significant contribution to the victory.

Defenders:

• Diogo Dalot (7/10): Solid defensively, Dalot offered good support going forward, contributing to the attacking play down the right flank. His crosses, however, could have been more precise.

• Raphael Varane (8/10): A commanding presence at the back, Varane’s experience and leadership were crucial in keeping Newcastle's potent attack at bay. He won almost every aerial duel and made crucial interceptions. A rock-solid performance.

• Lisandro Martinez (7.5/10): Martinez's tenacity and aggression were key in disrupting Newcastle's rhythm. He was involved in several vital tackles and clearances, solidifying the defensive unit.

• Luke Shaw (7/10): Shaw offered consistent support down the left flank, providing width and linking up well with the midfielders. Defensively, he was solid, rarely giving Newcastle’s wingers any space.

Midfielders:

• Casemiro (8/10): The midfield maestro once again controlled the tempo of the game, dictating play and breaking up Newcastle's attacks. His defensive work was immaculate, and he showcased his passing range, creating opportunities for the attackers. A Man of the Match contender.

• Bruno Fernandes (7/10): Fernandes, though not at his dazzling best, still had moments of brilliance. His vision and passing created several chances, and his work-rate remained exemplary. His influence on the game is undeniable even on an "off" day.

• Mason Mount (6.5/10): Mount worked tirelessly, but his impact on the game wasn’t as significant as his midfield partners. He showed glimpses of his potential but lacked the final ball in several key moments.

Forwards:

• Marcus Rashford (8/10): Rashford was a constant threat throughout the match, showcasing his pace and dribbling skills. He caused havoc for the Newcastle defense and was unlucky not to score more than one goal. His directness was a key factor in United’s attacking potency.

• Antony (6/10): Antony’s performance was a mixed bag. While his skillful dribbling was evident, his final product lacked consistency. He needs to improve his decision-making in the final third.

• Zirkzee (5/10): This is where the debate starts. While Zirkzee had limited minutes, his impact was arguably minimal. He didn’t show the clinical edge expected of a striker, failing to capitalize on the limited opportunities presented to him. He needs to improve his movement and positioning to maximize his chances. This raises the question: Is Zirkzee truly ready for a starting role, or is his potential yet to be fully realized?

Newcastle United Player Ratings: A valiant effort, but ultimately insufficient

Newcastle's performance, while valiant, wasn't enough to secure a victory against a strong Manchester United side. Their individual ratings reflect this. We highlight some key players:

• Nick Pope (6.5/10): Pope made some excellent saves, but he couldn't prevent all the goals. A solid performance, but he couldn’t single-handedly stem the tide.

• Sven Botman (7/10): Botman was one of Newcastle's standout performers at the back. His composure and ability to read the game were evident.

• Alexander Isak (6/10): Isak was relatively quiet, struggling to make a significant impact against a well-organized United defense.

Analyzing Zirkzee’s Performance: The Verdict?

Zirkzee's low rating (5/10) reflects his limited impact on the game. While it's unfair to judge a player solely on a short cameo appearance, his lack of decisive contributions raises legitimate questions about his readiness for a prominent role in the team. His movement off the ball needs improvement, and he needs to demonstrate a more clinical touch in front of goal. Is Zirkzee finished? Not necessarily. It's too early to write him off completely. He's still young, and with more playing time and proper coaching, he could still fulfill his potential. However, this performance highlights the need for significant improvement.

Factors affecting Zirkzee’s rating:

• Limited Playing Time: A fair assessment requires sufficient game time. Zirkzee's short appearance makes it hard to fully judge his potential.

• Lack of Service: The quality of service to the striker can heavily influence performance. If he wasn't receiving adequate passes, his lack of goals isn't entirely his fault.

• Team Dynamics: Integrating into a new team takes time. Adapting to teammates' playing styles and understanding the team's tactical approach takes time.

Ultimately, the question of whether Zirkzee is "finished" is premature. This match serves as a crucial learning experience, and his future success depends on his reaction to this evaluation and his dedication to improving his weaknesses.

Conclusion: A Tale of Two Teams

The Manchester United vs. Newcastle match presented a stark contrast in performances. Manchester United demonstrated their strength and depth, while Newcastle, despite a valiant effort, couldn't overcome the superior quality of their opponents. Zirkzee’s performance, however, remains a point of discussion, prompting questions about his future and his readiness for the demands of Premier League football. Only time will tell whether he can bounce back from this relatively disappointing appearance. Further analysis will be needed to fully assess his long-term potential within the team.